As South Africa considers proposals encouraging the employment of doctors by private hospitals in an effort to contain healthcare costs, a new study by  at Rice University and Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas (BCBSTX), has found that it could in effect an increase in healthcare costs without any evidence that patients get better treatment.

In the paper published in the Journal of General Internal Medicine, the researchers note that as hospitals gain more control over physicians, they may incentivise delivery of more services but not necessarily higher quality care.

“When we launched this study, we hypothesised that tighter integration of physicians with hospitals would improve care coordination,” said Vivian Ho, lead author and the James A. Baker III Institute Chair in Health Economics and director of the Centre for Health and Biosciences at Rice’s Baker Institute for Public Policy. “For example, less duplicate testing might occur, which would lower costs. That hypothesis didn’t play out in the data.”

The tightest form of integration occurs when hospitals directly employ physicians, but physicians also become integrated with hospitals when they jointly contract for services with an insurer.

In 2003, approximately 29% of US hospitals employed physicians, a number that rose to 42% by 2012. The share of physician practices owned by hospitals rose from 14% in 2012 to 29% in 2016. Economists refer to these relationships between hospitals and physicians as vertical integration, because they represent hospitals exerting more control over physicians as an essential part of inpatient care.

The researchers analysed all preferred provider organization (PPO) insurance claims processed for care through BCBSTX from 2014 through 2016 in Texas’ four largest metropolitan areas – Dallas, Houston, San Antonio and Austin. The population in these areas totalled 18.9 million in 2017, greater than the population of 46 US states. The sample included all claims for healthcare services for patients aged 19 to 64 except for prescription drugs.

Several studies have found that vertical integration of physicians with hospitals is associated with higher annual spending, but none of these studies concurrently measured the relation between vertical integration and quality, the researchers said.

In their study, they examined claims to determine whether patients had visited a primary care physician (PCP) and, if so, which PCP they saw most frequently. The researchers attributed roughly 500 000 to 600 000 patients to a PCP for each year and used BCBSTX contracting data to determine whether each of these physicians worked in a physician-owned practice or one that was hospital-owned. The researchers then compared the annual spending for patients treated by doctors in physician- versus hospital-owned practices.

They found patients with PPO insurance coverage incur spending that is 5.8% higher when treated by doctors in hospital-owned versus physician-owned practices. The difference appears attributable to greater service use rather than higher prices. For four out of five common diagnostic tests (for example, X-rays and MRIs), claims per patient were equal to or higher in hospital- versus physician-owned practices. There was no consistent difference in quality of care (for example, 30-day hospital readmission rates, diabetic care or screening mammography) for hospital-owned versus physician-owned practices.

“Healthcare costs continue to rise faster than the growth rate of the overall economy,” said Ho, who is also a professor of economics at Rice and a professor of medicine at Baylor College of Medicine. “Tighter integration of physicians with hospitals appears to be contributing to that cost growth, with no evidence of better quality.”

Higher spending ultimately translates into higher insurance premiums for customers, said Leanne Metcalfe, executive director of research and strategy at BCBSTX and a co-author of the study.

“Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services regulators should be wary of the burden that increasing reporting requirements place on physicians in small, independent practices,” Metcalfe said. “In the long run, these requirements may have the unintended consequence of raising healthcare costs.”


Reference: Ho, V, et al. Annual Spending
per Patient and Quality in Hospital-Owned Versus Physician-Owned Organizations:
an Observational Study. Journal of Internal Medicine. Published 3 September